The radius mistake starts with the wrong dimension
Most extrusion-bending failures begin in the drawing, before a die or machine is selected. A specification such as R = k t, where t is wall thickness, may look precise, but it is not a general law for aluminum extrusions.
That shortcut works reasonably well for a uniform strip bent about its thin direction because the wall thickness is also the material depth across the bend. A hollow extrusion is different. Its wall may be 2 mm thick while the complete profile is 20, 40, or 100 mm deep in the bend plane.
The dimension that controls the primary tensile demand is the distance from the neutral axis to the farthest tensile fiber. Wall thickness remains important, but mainly for local buckling, wrinkling, ovalization, and cross-section stability.
For a bent extrusion, calculate strain at the farthest fiber first. Treat wall-thickness ratios as a stability check, not as the radius formula.
Build the radius from strain, not from a multiplier
During ideal bending, a neutral longitudinal fiber does not change length. Every other fiber follows the same bend angle but travels along a different arc radius. The difference in those arc lengths creates tensile and compressive strain.
Let Rn be the radius to the neutral axis. Let yt be the distance from that axis to the farthest tensile surface and yc the distance to the farthest compression surface. A first-pass strain calculation is:
- Tensile-side engineering strain: εt ≈ yt / Rn
- Compression-side engineering strain: εc ≈ -yc / Rn
The formula assumes that the neutral fiber keeps its original length and that the cross-section remains reasonably stable. At larger curvatures, true tensile strain is better represented by ln(1 + yt / Rn). The engineering expression is still useful for screening, but a 20 percent engineering strain is already a severe forming demand for many aluminum tempers.
For a symmetric profile with total depth H in the bend direction, the neutral axis is approximately centered, so yt = H/2. If the drawing gives an inside radius Ri measured to the nearest surface, then:
- Rn = Ri + H/2
- εt ≈ H / (2Ri + H)
If a validated process strain limit is εallow, the corresponding screening radius is:
- Ri,min ≈ H/2 × (1/εallow - 1)
For a flat strip bent across its thickness, H equals t. That is the special case that makes a thickness multiplier appear reliable. For a tube or architectural extrusion, H is the overall diameter or profile depth in the bend plane, not the wall thickness.
Keeping inside, centerline, and outside radii separate is essential; a concise radius formula framework helps prevent a correct calculation from being applied to the wrong radius reference.
Why hollow profiles expose the weakness of wall-thickness rules
Consider a 20 mm square tube with a 2 mm wall and a 40 mm inside radius. The nominal radius-to-wall-thickness ratio is 20:1, which may appear conservative under a simple fabrication rule.
The strain calculation tells a different story:
- Overall bend-plane depth: H = 20 mm
- Neutral-axis radius: Rn = 40 + 10 = 50 mm
- Farthest tensile distance: yt = 10 mm
- Outer-fiber strain: εt = 10 / 50 = 20 percent
Whether that tube cracks depends on its alloy, temper, surface condition, and forming method, but 20 percent is an aggressive tensile demand for many harder aluminum conditions. The 2 mm wall does not make the outside surface experience only 2 mm of bending strain.
Round tubes make the distinction even clearer. For a tube with outside diameter D, the approximate outer-fiber strain is based on D/2:
- D / (2Rn) estimates longitudinal tensile strain.
- D/t indicates susceptibility to flattening, ovalization, and local instability.
Those ratios answer different questions. Using D/t as a substitute for D/(2Rn) is one of the most common radius errors in tube and extrusion design.
A hollow section is lighter because it removes material near the center of the section. It does not move the outer wall closer to the neutral axis. The void reduces weight, but the farthest fibers still travel longer arcs during bending.
The same principle applies to solid rectangular bar. If the bar is bent about its 3 mm thickness, the relevant depth may be 3 mm. If it is bent about a 50 mm width, the relevant depth becomes 50 mm. The bend direction determines which dimension belongs in the strain calculation.
One profile, two orientations, two answers
Take a 40 mm by 20 mm rectangular tube with a 2 mm wall and specify a 100 mm inside radius. The wall thickness and nominal radius-to-thickness ratio remain unchanged regardless of orientation.
If the 40 mm dimension lies in the radial direction:
- H = 40 mm
- Rn = 100 + 20 = 120 mm
- yt = 20 mm
- εt = 20 / 120 = 16.7 percent
Rotate the same profile so the 20 mm dimension lies in the radial direction:
- H = 20 mm
- Rn = 100 + 10 = 110 mm
- yt = 10 mm
- εt = 10 / 110 = 9.1 percent
The nominal Ri/t ratio is 50 in both cases. The tensile demand is nearly twice as high in the first orientation.
Suppose a forming trial has established a maximum allowable tensile strain of 10 percent for the selected profile and temper. The strain-based inside-radius screens would be:
- For H = 40 mm: Ri,min ≈ 40/2 × (1/0.10 - 1) = 180 mm
- For H = 20 mm: Ri,min ≈ 20/2 × (1/0.10 - 1) = 90 mm
At a 100 mm inside radius, the shallow orientation passes this particular strain screen while the deep orientation does not. Rotating the profile can therefore be more effective than changing tooling, provided the orientation still satisfies load paths, torsional stiffness, appearance, drainage, and tool-clearance requirements.
Geometry sets demand; material sets capacity
The profile geometry determines how much the outer surface must stretch. Alloy and temper determine how much strain the material can tolerate before cracking or developing unacceptable surface damage.
6063 generally forms more readily than 6061-T6, while softer or annealed conditions usually tolerate tighter forming than fully hardened tempers. Those are useful tendencies, not universal radius values. Two extrusions made to the same alloy and temper can still behave differently because of profile shape, extrusion direction, corner geometry, die lines, residual stress, and surface condition.
A tensile datasheet elongation should not be treated as an automatic allowable bend strain. Tensile elongation is measured over a defined coupon gauge length. Bending concentrates strain at a short outer surface, where scratches, die lines, sharp corners, or local section changes can trigger a crack before the nominal material elongation is reached.
A defensible εallow should come from supplier process data, a qualified bend trial, or a validated forming simulation supported by physical samples. If the required radius is appearance-critical or the profile will be anodized, the acceptable strain may need to be lower than the value that merely avoids a visible fracture.
Wall thickness still matters, but for a different failure mode
The strain calculation catches the risk of stretching the outer surface beyond the material's forming capacity. It does not guarantee that the inside of the profile will remain stable.
Wall thickness and local geometry become decisive when:
- A thin inner wall wrinkles under compression.
- A wide unsupported web buckles between stiff corners.
- A round tube ovalizes or collapses.
- A multi-chamber extrusion distorts unevenly.
- A sharp local corner concentrates stress and disrupts material flow.
A mandrel, wiper die, internal support, or stretch-bending setup can improve cross-section stability. None of them removes the distance between the neutral axis and the outermost fiber. Tooling can prevent a wall from collapsing, but it cannot make a 40 mm-deep profile behave like a 2 mm strip.
A useful way to express the design decision is:
- Ri,design = max(Ri,strain, Ri,stability, Ri,tooling)
The strain term can be screened with geometry. The stability and tooling terms depend on wall slenderness, unsupported spans, alloy condition, friction, support, and the exact forming process. They usually require supplier experience, section analysis, or physical qualification rather than one universal equation.
Springback belongs to a separate step. Overbending or CNC compensation can correct the final angle and radius after release, but it should not be used to justify a radius that already exceeds the tensile or compression limits of the profile.
Asymmetric profiles require the neutral axis, not H/2
The simple H/2 relationship applies to a symmetric section. Channels, T-sections, offset frames, and multi-chamber profiles often have their centroid away from the visual middle of the section.
For those profiles, calculate the distance from the neutral axis to every extreme surface. The tensile-side value yt may belong to a flange corner rather than the outermost point that appears obvious in the drawing. The compression-side value yc may be different, so the two sides can have different failure risks.
For an initial elastic estimate, the neutral axis of a uniform material section is associated with the section centroid. As forming progresses into plastic deformation, material flow and cross-section distortion can move the effective neutral zone. That is why a complex profile may pass a simple global strain calculation but still crack at a corner or wrinkle in a thin chamber.
For unusual sections, use a section model or forming simulation to identify the critical fiber, then confirm the result with a short production-equivalent sample. A radius quoted without the bend axis, profile orientation, or reference surface leaves too much of the calculation undefined.
A production-ready radius specification
A radius requirement becomes usable when it carries the variables that control the strain:
- State the radius reference. Specify inside, centerline, or outside radius. These values differ by approximately the profile depth across the bend.
- Identify the bend axis and orientation. State which profile dimension lies in the radial direction.
- List alloy and temper. Include the actual extrusion condition, not only the alloy family.
- Record section geometry. Provide overall bend-plane depth, wall thickness, unsupported spans, chambers, and critical corners.
- Run the strain screen. Use yt/Rn for the tensile side and yc/Rn for compression rather than relying only on Ri/t.
- Check local stability and tooling. Confirm whether the profile needs a mandrel, wiper, internal support, stretch bending, or a larger radius.
- Qualify the first part. Inspect the outer tensile surface, inner compression surface, cross-sectional dimensions, final radius, and springback after release.
A drawing that says only minimum radius equals five times wall thickness is incomplete for a hollow extrusion. A stronger specification identifies the radius reference and bend plane, then gives the profile geometry needed to calculate the actual fiber strain.
The design rule worth keeping
Use y/Rn to determine how much the profile must stretch. Use wall thickness, D/t, unsupported width, and chamber geometry to determine whether the section can remain stable while that stretch occurs.
For aluminum extrusions, minimum bend radius is not a magic wall-thickness multiplier. It is the result of profile depth, bend orientation, neutral-axis geometry, material capacity, and cross-section stability. Once those variables are separated, radius decisions become easier to audit, easier to quote, and far less likely to fail during production.