On 11-19, at a lakeside villa in Shenzhen, Trump, Xi and Putin held the first trilateral summit between the leaders of the three countries — about an hour and a half, on the sidelines of APEC — and issued a joint statement they called a "Declaration toward Peace." On 11-16 I wrote that the three governments did not agree on what the summit was for. The declaration is what that disagreement looks like once it is written down: four commitments, and neither of the two wars that were actually on the table.
What it says, as distributed by China and Russia and reported by the BBC, AP and RFE/RL:
- The UN should be reformed by the countries that hold its veto, without saying what is broken.
- The three countries will "increase the production and supply of refined petroleum products."
- "The principle of state consent and respect for immunities of State officials are of paramount importance," and the International Criminal Court and "other similar bodies must not abuse their jurisdiction."
- "A nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought," plus a "dialogue" on reducing nuclear risk — no date, venue or agenda.
What it does not say: Ukraine and Iran. AP notes the declaration names neither Russia's war in Ukraine nor the US-led war in Iran. Trump said he raised Iran, and that he and Putin had a "long discussion" on Ukraine; Putin said the conflict in Ukraine was among their shared interests. Peskov, Putin's spokesman, said it was not the main topic of the three-way. None of it reached the page. Newsweek, which dissected the text, called the declaration's most concrete commitment a thank-you note to China for hosting.
Two clauses carry more weight than the rest.
The immunity clause is about accountability, and the accountability runs one way. Putin is wanted by the ICC — a March 2023 warrant over the abduction of Ukrainian children. The US opposes the court's warrant for Netanyahu. None of the three countries is a member of the court. A statement that courts should mind their own business, signed by three leaders with an interest in courts minding their own business, is not a peace term; it is an exit.
The petroleum clause lands on Russia's oil sector, which funds the war and is under Ukrainian drone and missile attack, and it lands while the US and Iran both keep blockades around the Strait of Hormuz. Newsweek asked the obvious follow-up: will China press Iran toward a deal that lifts the blockade, or will Trump ease sanctions so Russia can sell more oil?
The declaration was signed between two nights of bridge strikes.
Ukraine hit the Crimean Bridge for the third time in four days. The first two strikes, on 11-16 and 11-17, shifted one arch and then collapsed the span of road deck over the Kerch Strait; car traffic stopped, and train traffic resumed the same day. The third strike, overnight on 11-19, went after the railway section with Neptune coastal missile systems — the same weapon that sank the Moskva in 2022 — according to Ukraine's General Staff. Russia's answer came overnight on 11-19/20 and was, by Zelensky's account, one of the largest attacks of the war: more than 110 missiles, 27 of them ballistic, and about 400 drones. The Air Force said 462 were downed and strikes landed at 23 locations. Three Kyiv bridges over the Dnipro were hit — the Podilsko-Voskresensky, Darnytskyi and Southern — and the mayor, Vitali Klitschko, said three people were killed and 15 injured; Ukrainian media put the Kyiv toll at six. Two people were killed at a railway station in Lviv. Poland said its airspace was violated. Bloomberg's frame is the causal one: three Kyiv bridges hit after Putin vowed revenge for the Crimean Bridge, having promised retaliation "far more painful" than the strike itself.
That is the thing to watch, and not the declaration. As Elizabeth Wishnick told RFE/RL, it was not a coincidence that Ukraine struck the bridge shortly before the summit — it was a message that the great powers cannot end this war without Ukraine and Europe in the room. "The days of leaders sitting around a table and deciding the fate of the world are over," she said. The Ukraine diplomacy that day happened somewhere else: Trump dialed into the Coalition of the Willing meeting in Berlin, where his envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff sat with Zelensky and more than 40 European leaders, and the UK pledged 1,000 long-range strike drones.
Sources:
- BBC, "Trump, Putin and Xi release 'peace declaration' following unprecedented meeting"
- AP via PBS NewsHour, "3 takeaways from Trump, Xi and Putin's historic summit"
- RFE/RL, "Trump, Xi, and Putin Make History, But No Breakthroughs"
- Newsweek, "Trump, Xi and Putin's Warless Peace Declaration: Dissected"
- Politico, "Trump, Xi, Putin take aim at International Criminal Court"
- Kyiv Independent, "Ukrainian forces once more hit Russia's Crimean Bridge"
- UNITED24 Media, "Ukraine's Neptune Missiles Strike Crimean Bridge"
- BBC, "Three Kyiv bridges hit during major Russian missile attack"
- Ukrainska Pravda, "Ukraine strikes three Russian ballistic missile launchers overnight"
- Bloomberg, "Three Kyiv Bridges Hit by Russia after Putin Vowed Revenge for Crimean Bridge"